With the dreadful news from Burma, what are the odds on Illustrious being offered as an aid platform? She is still in the Indian Ocean- on exercise with the
Indian Navy.
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Sunk at Narvik |
Odds on Illustrious going to Burma? |
Lead | |
|
Posts: 2242 ( 6-May-2008 15:18:02) |
With the dreadful news from Burma, what are the odds on Illustrious being offered as an aid platform? She is still in the Indian Ocean- on exercise with the
Indian Navy.
|
||
Jim WH |
|||
|
Posts: 912 ( 6-May-2008 15:55:41) |
None: the Burmese government will not have a British ship come to their aid, and Whitehall would have to know this.
|
||
CVA02 |
|||
|
Posts: 385 ( 7-May-2008 00:06:29) |
I would think that the paranoid Burmese regime would be especially paranoid about Great Britain. In any event, this catastrophic typhoon was hardly unexpected,
although the media typically gets a bit overwrought about the sort of natural disasters that are unremarkable historically in this part of the world. Remember
that every event of annual flooding in Bangladesh is reported as a singular catastrophe, despite the fact that it happens every year, in varying degrees of
severity. Now is the time for deep reflection, not about typhoons, monsoons and tsunamis, but the base and condescending nature of western philanthropy. NGOs
used the Indonesian tsunami as an excuse for lavish and self aggrandizing fund raising, navies used the disaster as a convenient photo op, and squatters from
unaffected, inland areas quickly rushed into the destroyed and deserted coastal areas to collect undeserved aid, while the true victims were for the most part,
drowned, dead and washed out to sea. The true disaster was the poverty and desperation in Banda Aceh, a condition that had existed long before the tsunami.
Ironically, the massive infusion of aid money served to make on of the poorest regions of Indonesia relatively affluent in the short term, helping to end the
civil war. We should all step back and appreciate the continuing, daily human tragedy in Myanmar/Burma, remembering that disaster and suffering is a daily
experience for the Burmese people.
|
||
bager1968 |
|||
|
Posts: 2926 ( 7-May-2008 21:12:55) |
On today's news, a UN spokesman said that, while they have been given permission to fly supplies into Burma, none of their aid workers have been given
Visas (and so could not enter the country)... which meant the Burmese government's position is:
"Give us the supplies, but keep out of our country. We will distribute the supplies where we want them to go, not where you say they are needed." Ethiopia did this during the first stage of the mid-1980s famine relief efforts, and it was found that all the food was going to tribes in favor with the government... which were doing well on their own... and not to the starving, who were from tribes the government didn't like. Only when the world's relief agencies threatened to cut off all aid were they allowed to make sure the food got to those actually starving. |
||