Yuku free message boards

I've always thought that the site never tells us how the Imperial Japanese Navy was a near complete failure of a military force. Their only real successes were a peacetime surprise attack on Pearl Harbour in Dec 1941, followed by a win over inferior forces at Java Sea in Feb 1942. To be fair, IIRC, they were land-based naval pilots that sank PoW and Repulse, so perhaps we'll give that score to the IJN too. Next in March and April 1942, the IJN completely fails to engage the main British fleet off Ceylon, where success in this mission could have brought down Churchill's government. Then in May 1942, we have essentially a draw between the now battle experienced IJN and the arguably less inexperienced USN at Coral Sea. Then it's all over for the Japanese Navy at Midway in June 1942, where the IJN loses four out of their six fleet carriers, plus a large number of their highly trained aircrews, leaving only Zuikaku and Shōkaku, plus the slow and small light carriers Ryūjō, Junyo, and Hiyo, plus a fleet of obsolete and/or non-relevant battleships, most to be lost shortly through suicidal missions.

So, within seven months of starting the Pacific War, Japan's IJN lost it's entire offensive capability, while leaving both the USN and (less importantly) the RN intact to continue the battle on their terms. Meanwhile the remaining rump of the IJN was entirely unable to defend its territories, nor come up with any credible ASW tactics to stop the USN and RN submarines was sinking their transports and warships. Lastly, the IJN's aircraft and pilot procurement was woefully inadequate and unprepared for the coming war.

If I was writing for the Combined Fleet website, the home page would have a note on the home page giving tribute to the brave Japanese men who got sent to die in war via a poorly led fleet that shone brightly in Dec 1941, and was at the bottom of the sea seven months later. Compare this to the RN, with the exception of Ark Royal, every one of their large fleet carriers in active service in 1941/2 survived the war, including the four Illustrious class, which saw major combat on all fronts.

While no navy was perfect, I think the IJN remains the only major fleet to have its entire offensive capability wiped out within seven months of joining the war, along with no plans or ability to replace lost ships. Imagine if the RN acted the same as the IJN? Throughout the war the RN continued to keep its offensive capability, even with the loss of five carriers, five battleships, and countless cruisers and destroyers. However, it's not the IJN's fault that Japan couldn't build ships, planes and pilots to keep up with loses. But their failues at Ceylon, Coral Sea and Midway are truely their own, as they should have smashed Sommerville entirely, and then used their supposed expertise to kill the USN at Coral Sea.