Yuku free message boards

Good question. I also have considered it before, but not worked it out. Bassically a monitor is not a very good seagoing vessel, as it is very slow and shallow drafted, but it is a stable gunplatform. It is however armored and can take a beating, especially against non armor piercing shells, while the large bulge gives good torpedoprotection. Disadvantage is the armament placed in a single heavy turret, that does not give good arc of fire and the unshielded secondary armament. The very bit 15 inch guns are likely to be very slow fireing and therefore not so good in a very short range battle. Most likely the heavy shell will go right through an unarmored target at point blanc ranges, without exploding. (even the HE shell will have such an effect.) Best is the 4 inch secondary armament, which is very fast fireing, but not protected at all, sdo very vulnerable to enemy fire.

HMS Roberts or a simmilar monitor is likely to survive HSK-8, as the German ship cannot sink it with gunfire alone and has to score multiple torpeodhits to defeat it completely. Otherwise the Monitor may not be able to seriously engage the raider, as long as range is too close and her secondary guns are out of action, due to enemy fire. (When disengaging a single lucky hit at longer range from the 15 inch guns can however change things completely.)

What about an old pre-Dreadnought era armored first class cruiser, like a Drake or Scharnhorst class vessel? These vessels were not actually anymore in teh time of WW2, although some Chilean vessels were still around. Armored they were and they had only two electrically driven turrets and many manually operated armored gunmountings, which could not be pierced by HE shells of 5.9 inch and certainly packed a lot of punch to hose back. The single torpedohit foreward would be a problem, but as this was likely foreward of the bridge, it would likely not sink the vessel outright. It could remain afloat and minus her foreward turret, it still had quite a lot of guns left to engage the enemy. Likewise, it also mounted old stile underwater torpedotubes, which at the given range could also be deployed.